After asking a patient if she would like to be prayed for, Caroline Petrie, a community nurse working in the United Kingdom, was suspended from her job.
Petrie faced disciplinary action and the possible loss of her job. At the time of the incident, she was told that she had to "demonstrate a personal and professional commitment to equality and diversity" and that she could not use her "professional status to promote causes that are not related to health."
Petrie insisted that she never tried to force her religious beliefs on any of her patients, but simply asked if the patient wanted her to pray for her.
Although she was reinstated, the incident highlights the "line in the sand" that is often drawn when it comes to mixing religion and medicine. The intersection between faith, science, and healing is still hazy for many practitioners, and some are uncomfortable bringing spiritual practice into the care paradigm. But in this era of increasingly holistic care, it has become clear that religious and spiritual beliefs and practices are important to many patients. This can be particularly pronounced in people facing a potentially terminal disease, such as cancer, where one's own mortality suddenly becomes very real.
Polls and surveys show that more than 90% of Americans believe in God or a universal spirit, but the spiritual needs of patients and their families are not always obvious to healthcare professionals, said Stephen King, PhD, manager of chaplaincy at the Seattle Cancer Care Alliance. Unfortunately, the spiritual needs of patients might not be addressed until the disease reaches an advanced stage, or might not be addressed at all. While chaplains have an important role, everyone involved in the patient's care has a role to play in addressing the spiritual needs of cancer patients.
Awareness Needed
Spirituality and religion are different concepts, although they often overlap. Aligning with a specific religion indicates adherence to certain beliefs and dogma, whereas spirituality has been described as an awareness of something greater than the individual self. People can express their spirituality through religion and prayer or through other paths of spiritual pursuit and expression.
The spiritual component of care is one that patients are asking for, noted Robert Klitzman, MD, professor of clinical psychiatry and director of the masters of bioethics program at Columbia University in New York City. It is extremely important to many patients with cancer and other chronic illnesses, and doctors need to be aware of that.
In the late-19th century, medicine distanced itself from what is now considered holistic treatment. Medicine wanted to become very scientific and rejected anything that wasn't scientific. But the reality is very different for the patient: someone experiencing cancer and possibly facing the end of life doesn't think of science as one thing and spiritual issues as something else — they are seen as one and the same.